The IUP Journal of Accounting Research and Audit Practices:
Using the Benford Datasets and the Reddy and Sebastin Results to Form an Audit Alert Screening Heuristic: An Appraisal
Article Details
Pub. Date
:
Jul,
2014
Product Name
:
The IUP Journal of Accounting Research and Audit Practices
Product Type
:
Article
Product Code
:
IJARAP41407
Author Name
:
Edward J Lusk and Michael Halperin
Availability
:
YES
Subject/Domain
:
Finance
Download Format
:
PDF Format
No.
of Pages
:
14
Price
For delivery in electronic
format: Rs. 50;
For delivery through courier (within India): Rs.
50 + Rs. 25 for Shipping & Handling Charges
Download
To download this Article click on the button below:
Abstract
Digital Frequency Testing (DFT) is a simple and potentially effective tool that can be used efficiently in the certification audit as well as in the service of forensic investigations to rationalize the use of extended audit procedures at the substantive phase of the audit. To further the hegemony of DFT, this paper summarizes certain aspects of the excellent treatment of DFT offered by Reddy and Sebastin (2012). In the following, the paper takes up the development of a Benford Screening Window (BSW) that can be employed to create alerts as to when datasets under audit examination do not seem to conform to the DFT profile as corrected from the Benford (1938) paper. The BSW is tested vis-à-vis the log10expectation function, two accounting industry datasets downloaded from COMPUSTATTM, and the 12 years of in-kind committee contributions dataset developed by Reddy and Sebastin (2012). The paper finds a reasonable fit for these datasets for the BSW and hence suggests an overall calibration cut-off taken from the results obtained by passing the Reddy-Sebastin datasets through the BSW. In this paper, the authors have programmed an ExcelTMVBA driven Decision Support System (DSS) to aid in the creation of these audit alerts which is available for free as a download with no restriction on its use.
Description
Digital Frequency Testing (DFT) is a simple and potentially effective tool that can be used
efficiently in certification audit as well as in the service of forensic investigations to rationalize
the use of extended audit procedures at the substantive phase of the audit. Reddy and Sebastin
(2012), in their study—“Entropic Analysis in Financial Forensics”—have offered an excellent
treatment of DFT. Their study is, without doubt, a standard reading in auditing and assurance
courses. This is to say that their work represents the important blend of academics and application
that gives credential validity to their treatment of forensic testing as it relates to the audit
context.
Commenting on the nature of the study by Reddy and Sebastin (2012), in the present paper
we derive a practical screening window from corrections that we made to the Benford dataset
that can be used to create possible audit alert information to aid in the decision regarding the
use of extended audit procedures at the substantive testing phase. The Appendix offers the
discussion of a Decision Support System (DSS) that we have created to facilitate the creation of
the requisite audit alert information.
Keywords
Accounting Research and Audit Practices, Digital Frequency Testing (DFT), Benford Screening Window (BSW), Decision Support System (DSS), Benford Datasets, Reddy, Sebastin Results, Form, Audit Alert Screening Heuristic.